This was a lot of fun, a good balance of skill challenges and combat, roleplay as well. It did take my party of 4 level 3 players a long time to complete, but I think that was on them and not as much on the adventure. My only real issue is that there is a magic scimitar from the Dog and Trumpet encounter that isn't in Appendix B as stated. Instead there is a Longsword called Knightfall that I never found reference to in the Pontly vault, or anywhere else for that matter. It made me wonder if either I missed something somewhere or if the scimitar was supposed to be the longsword or vice versa. But the longsword was clearly a Pontly item, and the scimitar did not seem to be related.