This is a tremendous supplement from beginning to end. Compelling characters, a killer adventure (who doesn’t love a mutiny?), eye-catching maps—all the stuff you’d expect from a Jimmy Meritt & Co release. But the little details really set it apart. What other modules contain fully rendered menus for their taverns, or provide rules for cheating in a pirate dice game, or furnish your group with an original song to play in the bar? If you’re looking for an exciting and robust maritime adventure, you can’t do better than this.

This is a tremendous alternative to a standard paint-by-numbers dungeon crawl. The memorable scenarios, awesome maps, and diversity of challenge-types made it a must-buy for me.