Just finished this converted adventure module. It was also our first serious 5e adventure. So a learning curve for them and me. Both for the 20+ yrs roleplayers and the newbies to roleplay. I really enjoyed the additions. Especially the encounter in the tailorshop which showed the party (5 players, 1 wizard and 4 fighter-based classes) that some fights can go wrong really fast if they aren't careful. And it showed the variety of roles races have and that alignment is not fixed in Eberron. It was worth every penny and I can't wait to start Shadows of the Last War next month. Great work Stuart! Hope you will continue on the Grasp of the Emerald Claw and maybe Whispers of the Vampire's Blade, even with its issues.

This will be my first attempt at being the DM, and I can safely say this is the best adaptation of the original Forgotten Forge campaign. I highly recommend you buying this and keeping an eye out for the conversions of the continuations of this campaign!

Just used this conversion to help prepare for a one-shot and it's well worth the price--likely more. The additions to the story help make it seem more real and less like a railroad and can easily fluff the Forgotten Forge out into a two-session story. I think the difficulty might need a little tweaking as some of the fights were a hair on the easy side but I fully understand how much dice luck and factor in.

Overall, one of the best bangs for my buck that I've purchased here.

I am a newbie DM with newbie players and this was invaluable. The original adventure was kind of bland, focusing mostly on getting through it quickly and getting into some fights. Our favorite encounters ended up being the aditions made. The difficulty might need a couple adjustments, since some of the fights are really easy for 5 squishy but powerful level 1 heroes and the "upgrades" can be a bit too much. But just with the ideas provided it was easy to come up with little changes and adapt it. Great job, do the next ones!

I'm a big Eberron fan and I've been wanting to run this adventure for my 5th Edition group for a while but the conversion work was too daunting. This product does all of that work for me and more. The conversion work is good - it elegantly converts enemies that would be an absolute pain to work out. There is a great deal of added value in the advice portion of the book and even entire additional encounters included. The production quality looks good too. I really like this produce and will be using it in my 5e game.