This conversion was very helpful, but I wasn't happy with the organization scheme and several mistakes. But, it was worth the cost.
After an early attempt to convert this myself, I realized how long it would take me, and that it would be worth the money to pay for this instead. However, I would have preferred the monster and trap conversions be listed directly under each area, rather than have to look in three different places for each location. The reference page numbers in the notes could have been supplemented by area numbers to make this cross-referencing easier. The single, double-sided printable reference sheet wasn't as advertised. It was at least two sheets, and took up almost a third of the whole document.
There were also a number of mistakes that could have been caught with more thorough editing. The traps in I11b and I11d are both converted to the same "Cursed Idol" trap, while the original had very different traps. There are no stats for the statue monster in area I6. And the hinged stairs trap mentions falling damage in the conversion, while the original had soft sand that avoided that damage.
Overall, I only paid about $2 for this, so I'd say what I got was worth it. But, due to what I found above, I can't give it five stars.
|